A German court has once again ruled in Valve's favour as part on an ongoing dispute about whether consumers should be allowed to resell their digital games on Steam.

　　German consumer group Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband had previously attempted to take Valve to court in 2010, and said back in July 2013 that they intended for their second lawsuit to go ahead before 2014.

　　Now, however, a Berlin court has taken Valve's side. "The Regional Court of Berlin has dismissed the lawsuit of German consumer watchdog group Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband ("VZBV") against Valve Inc. over the provisions in company's terms of service that prohibit the sale or transfer of user accounts on the Steam digital distribution platform," said legal eagles Osborne Clark in a statement (spotted by Eurogamer).

　　The reasons behind this decision have not been made public, and VZBV may now have the right to appeal.

　　VZBW's main argument is that consumers being unable to resell their Steam accounts goes against the German version of the first-sale doctrine--the doctrine that enables consumers to resell copyrighted products. The Court of Justice in the European Union ruled in 2012 that this doctrine, also known as exhaustion, applied to digital software, which might explain why VZBW felt it right to take a second crack at Valve.

　　"Even so, the ruling touches on hot issues of European copyright law and may have ramifications for the games industry and the used games market across all EU jurisdictions," concludes Osborne Clark.

　　You need a javascript enabled browser to watch videos.

　　Click To Unmute

　　Feedbackula - Steam Machine Madness!

　　How Alan Wake II Made Me Face My Fear of Horror Games

　　GameSpot's Top 10 Games of 2023Thompson: The Pop Culture Icon’s Strange Legacy - LoadoutFirearms Expert’s FAVORITE Weapons Of 2023State Of Gaming Handhelds In 2023How Lies of P Cracked the Souls GenreFeedbackula - Final Farewell Furore!Feedbackula - inFamous: Second Son ShoutingFeedbackula - Dark Souls II Graphical GrumbleFeedbackula - Batman Bluster Barrage!Feedbackula - Thief Stealth Sourness!Feedbackula - Irrational Closure Commotion!

　　Share

　　LinkEmbed

　　Size:640 × 360480 × 270

　　Start at: End at: Autoplay Loop

　　Want us to remember this setting for all your devices?

　　Sign up or Sign in now!

　　Please use a html5 video capable browser to watch videos.

　　This video has an invalid file format.

　　00:00:00

　　HTML5

　　Auto HD High Low

　　Report a problem

　　Sorry, but you can't access this content!

Please enter your date of birth to view this video

　　By clicking 'enter', you agree to GameSpot's

　　Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

　　enter